[jambutty]

I have just re-read the whole thread and all there is, is opposition to the idea of one off cup-ties and opinions why it wouldn’t work. Not a single positive alternative to the proposal or any indication to how it might be able to work – all negative. That’s not debate. It’s opposition without an alternative proposal.

* - posts by lancsdave.
#2* – leave things alone.
#3 – talked about rival fans and how they can’t be kept apart.
#6 – wouldn’t work not enough grounds to go round.
#9* - reasons why it wouldn’t work.
#11 – more objections.
#12 – more objections
#14 – drifted off topic
#17 – pitch wear.
#18* - police involvement.
#20 – read it for yourself.
#22* - you asked a question
#24 – read that for yourself as well.
#26 – called silly.
#27 – seems to want to keep replays.
#28 – what if argument.
#33* - questioning my reasons.
#34 – nothing constructive.
#35 – another question.
#36* - making the point that the more replays the more money the FA makes.
#38 – more what if questions.
#39 – another question.
#41 – another question.
#44 - ??????

accymel is right – there is no point in continuing with this thread because all the contributors are of the opinion that one off cup-ties wouldn’t work so they are right any anyone else is wrong.