View Single Post
Old 12-02-2011, 12:02   #315
Retlaw
I am Banned
 

Re: Accy Old Photo's - John Kelly's Album

Quote:
Originally Posted by blackburnlad View Post
By the way, I haven't changed the numbering at any point throughout this discussion, I have maintained since I started that No 1 whalley Road was at the corner of Peel Street and that No 13 was the Slaters Arms.

It is yourself Walter (and katex) who have moved the properties. Between you you have had the Hope & Anchor at 19,21,23,25 and 27 Whalley Road. My conclusion is, you are clueless.
You quoted the use of the 1909 map in placing those numberss on the properties, Nu 1 had been long gone before that 1909 map was printed, the first property was Nu 3, then the last property on that block was Nu 19, still is. As for adresses in service records, thats another great source or errors, found one bloke yesterday discharged to Pickle St, Church. During WW1 there were 1000's of clerks filling in forms, men from all over the country having to make sense of regional accents. Also we have the 1918 Absent Voters lists, men with wrong service numbers, wrong addresses, even men who had been dead for over two years.
I think you've jumped in on something you have little knowledge of, showing off, and your now trying to extricate your self and save face, by creating confusion.
Retlaw

Last edited by Retlaw; 12-02-2011 at 12:04.
Retlaw is offline   Reply With Quote