Should have the McCanns have recieved the libel payout??
 

The parents of Madeleine McCann have accepted £550,000 in libel damages over "utterly false and defamatory" claims that they were responsible for her death

do you think they should have received this?

Re: Should have the McCanns have recieved the libel payout??
 

I don't see how they can prove they are false until they find out what really happened. They may just had paid them £550,000 for killing their daughter.

Re: Should have the McCanns have recieved the libel payout??
 

think its a strange area, as the press cannot substansiate their claims, then i think it is grossly wrong to make em, i have not much time for the Mcanns but at the same time think the media were bang out of order.:confused:

Re: Should have the McCanns have recieved the libel payout??
 

In a word YES! It should have been ten times that amount for EACH newspaper.

Newspapers and the tabloids in particular are far too fond of presenting supposition as fact and it is high time they were brought to heel.

But the real villains of the piece are the general public who buy the newspapers.

Re: Should have the McCanns have recieved the libel payout??
 

I don't know there are some cracking headlines that we would miss if there was no tabloids. Like todays Pornocchio :D

Re: Should have the McCanns have recieved the libel payout??
 

I agree totally with you Neil.
Until little Maddie is found and it can be established what happened they are still suspects and therefore shouldn't recieve the payout now but it could have been put on hold until all the facts are known.
Only when they are proven innocent should they get the money imho.

Re: Should have the McCanns have recieved the libel payout??
 

But the money has gone into the “Find Maddie” fund.

Would you rather the money wasn’t used in an attempt to find the little girl?

Re: Should have the McCanns have recieved the libel payout??
 

Completely agree with you Neil, i know its gone into the find madeline fund but the fund is useless if they have indeed killed her.......thats not that i`m saying i think they have though.

Re: Should have the McCanns have recieved the libel payout??
 

No i am not.
There are other ways of funding it like they have been doing ever since she went missing.
All i am trying to say is that by being given this money they seem to suddenly be totally innocent when nobody knows what happened.
I don't think they had anything to do with it but until provern otherwise maybe the money should have been put on hold.

Re: Should have the McCanns have recieved the libel payout??
 

I don't believe they will ever find her. I think her kidnapper killed her when the media circus that her parents created showed how unique she was.

That media circus that the McCanns used to keep everyone thinking about Maddie is the same one they are now complaining about. Ironic isn't it?

Re: Should have the McCanns have recieved the libel payout??
 

Well I get the Star (purely for the football coverage you understand) and they were unmerciless on the McCanns last summer, I'm very easy going but I thought at the time that some of the things that were being written were a bit stong to say the least. One headline allbut said they had killed Maddie. Mind you I actually said in another thread that there is often apologies printed in the papers, especially the Star, its very poor journalism and they deserve everything they get, no sympathy what so ever

Re: Should have the McCanns have recieved the libel payout??
 

I think that it's right that the Express Group paid out to the Find Madeleine fund. Some of the things they printed were vicious and totally un-necessary. Did we need to be informed that Kate's nickname at uni was 'Hot Lips Healy'? That Kate and Gerry are swingers? That Gerry is not Madeleine's biological father? All of which has been denied by the family.

To come out with things like that was totally wrong, in my opinion.

How was that supposed to help matters?

Re: Should have the McCanns have recieved the libel payout??
 

By keeping them on page 1 as much as possible which is what they wanted - when it suited

Re: Should have the McCanns have recieved the libel payout??
 

...sure you do, Jaysay, sure you do, just like I buy Playboy purely for the articles in it. ;)

Re: Should have the McCanns have recieved the libel payout??
 

I don't supposed they wanted personal slander though, did they?

I don't think they wanted their pasts delved into, their marriage and infertility dissected and discussed and hurtful untrue comments made.

Re: Should have the McCanns have recieved the libel payout??
 

Yes, of course they should have been paid this money, the papers concerned said terrible things .. and admitted had to keep the story going somehow.

Even suggested they had sold their child due to financial difficulties amongst other outrageous claims.

Also slowed the investigation down, 'cause focus was put on them, which is unforgivable.

Re: Should have the McCanns have recieved the libel payout??
 

if they are innocent and i say if, aint that what most people would do if they thought it helped to recover their child? but what the press printed in instances was fabricated to sell newspapers hence the judgement. i fail to understand why anyone should think these guttersnipes should be allowed to get away with it.

Re: Should have the McCanns have recieved the libel payout??
 

Have to say i agree with Neil, all they have wanted since she went missing is to keep it front page news and like they say not all publicity is bad publicity.
Surely anything that keeps this in the minds of the public is better than nothing at all?

Re: Should have the McCanns have recieved the libel payout??
 

It is when the publicity concerned is nothing but constant sniping and character assassination. A hate campaign was started on the back of things printed in the media. The last thing they needed.

Re: Should have the McCanns have recieved the libel payout??
 

I do not agree with them making up stories - that is wrong.
If I remember correctly a lot of what was reported came from the Portuguese Police - they made them suspects etc.

I see they still have not been dealt with for the neglect that was the cause of Maddie going missing in the first place.

Re: Should have the McCanns have recieved the libel payout??
 

Doe anyone think they will ever be dealt with for leaving the children in the first place,

Re: Should have the McCanns have recieved the libel payout??
 

dupilcate posting
tried to cancel but unable to do so

Re: Should have the McCanns have recieved the libel payout??
 

Nudge nudge wink wink Wynonie, got any back copies, I like those kind of articles as well:rolleyes::D

Re: Should have the McCanns have recieved the libel payout??
 

im sure if they were a certain family from dewsbury they wouldn't receive a penny

Re: Should have the McCanns have recieved the libel payout??
 

here here... no they should not have been given any more and in fact I feel they ought to be in court for leaving their children alone:

Re: Should have the McCanns have recieved the libel payout??
 

I hope Maddie is safe and well somewhere,,,but even if she is ,she will probably look very different now...I am glad that money is going into the ""Find Maddie Fund""

Re: Should have the McCanns have recieved the libel payout??
 

Re: Should have the McCanns have recieved the libel payout??
 

leaving the kids alone is a differant argument, which if they were in court for it would suit me, i am damn near sure if you had been on the wrong side of a press report,you would view this differantly.:cool: