X... - Page 13

Stanleymad · 22-11-2008, 20:57

Tho have to disprove the 'uniqueness' of Diana's voice, just proved the theory to my daughter ....... listen to the Cranberries & imagine Diana singing it mmmm sound very samey to me

Now she could win it hands down with their songs

garinda · 22-11-2008, 21:04

Quote:

Originally Posted by andrewb

Diana was amazing tonight!

I agree, though my friend's in Gran Canaria didn't like her at all this week...still, they are now soooooooooo out of touch with anything remotely current, it's sad.

They asked me if I'd like Diana if she wasn't a homegirl, and my answer is yes.

I love her quirkyness, her vunerability, and her willowy beauty. I'd give anything to hear her sing the Ballad of Lucy Jordan by Marianne Faithfull, that would be sublime, heavenly.

Alexandera and Ruth were also on top form too, but I hope it's Rachel who's going home, despite Danni's tears in a bid to gain sympathy votes.

pipinfort · 22-11-2008, 21:13

Quote:

Originally Posted by andrewb

Diana was amazing tonight!

Have you been drinking..? I think she is getting worse each week, tuneless whiney nonsense..............Alexandra to win .....

Gayle · 22-11-2008, 21:15

Quote:

Originally Posted by pipinfort

Have you been drinking..? I think she is getting worse each week, tuneless whiney nonsense..............Alexandra to win .....

Actually, I agree - wasn't impressed this week.

garinda · 22-11-2008, 21:18

Quote:

Originally Posted by pipinfort

Have you been drinking..? I think she is getting worse each week, tuneless whiney nonsense..............Alexandra to win .....

We don't take your musical criticism too seriously.

After all it was you that put old Queen Robbie Williams on the Accy Web juke box.

Whoops, missed a comma and an and out there!

You put old Queen, and Robbie Williams on the Accy Web juke box.

pipinfort · 22-11-2008, 21:51

You got me...........

West Ender · 22-11-2008, 22:03

Though I'm usually very partisan for anyone/anything from my native area, I really can't stand Diana. She's false and, at times, her voice sounds ludicrous. The trouble is, I bet she could be really good if she dropped the gimmicks. I can't stand Rachel either. She's not too bad a singer, though not brilliant, but her attitude gets up my nose.

I thought Alexandra was fabulous tonight, Ruth a close second. Oggin is still no great shakes but has the cute factor and JLS are - a boy band, full stop. Nik, who doesn't like boy bands, thinks JLS are really good!

emzy · 22-11-2008, 22:14

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stanleymad

Tho have to disprove the 'uniqueness' of Diana's voice, just proved the theory to my daughter ....... listen to the Cranberries & imagine Diana singing it mmmm sound very samey to me

Now she could win it hands down with their songs

I was saying the same to my mum last week about her sounding like the cranberries (but mum doesnt know who the cranberries are

) I thought she was quite good at the beginning, but as time goes on im going off her

Cant you tell people are bringing new albums out in time for Xmas though, last week it was leona lewis, this week we have same difference and Rydian, both who have albums due out on monday.

Not too sure who I want to go this week though, missed the first two acts due to crying child

forceten · 22-11-2008, 22:18

I thought Diana was good. But then again I like her. Her voice is unique.

And she is homegrown as well. Lets just get behind her and give her some support.

Rachel for me is going this week. She can sing some songs, but her attitude is terrible. Not too sure who will be in the bottom two with her, but guess at JLS, whom I thought didn't do too well tonight, although I do like them. Wasnt' at there best for me tonight

forceten · 22-11-2008, 22:26

Quote:

Originally Posted by forceten

Rachel for me is going this week. She can sing some songs, but her attitude is terrible. Not too sure who will be in the bottom two with her, but guess at JLS, whom I thought didn't do too well tonight, although I do like them. Wasnt' at there best for me tonight

Just call me mystic meg

West Ender · 22-11-2008, 22:27

Blood and sand! Yodelling Diana is still surviving.

I'm typing with one eye on the telly and, now, waiting to see if horrible Rachel gets the boot. Fingers crossed.......

emzy · 22-11-2008, 22:35

Im doing the same lol

forceten · 22-11-2008, 22:36

Yes!!!!!!!!

garinda · 23-11-2008, 01:25

Rachel's time was up. She'd had more than one chance to shine, and only ever really did in the sing offs, when I presume she got to chose her own song.

I thought DFS were flat tonight, and considering they kept to the original arrangement, their voices sounded thin compared with Take That's.

As for Diana, she is Marmite.

I loathe Marmite, but I adore her.

pipinfort · 23-11-2008, 11:30

Diana is indeed like a yeast extract spread ,love her or hate her , and whats that Eunuch(

) or whatever he`s called....he should be back at primary school.