Political threads

Gayle · 19-02-2006, 21:47

Roy, I wonder, with the elections looming, whether it might be an idea to open a section purely for political threads. Obviously, I'm on here, as is Graham to answer for Labour and now the Lib Dem representative is hanging around it might prompt a Conservative to join in. Could lead to some interesting debates. Also, would mean that anyone who wasn't interested could avoid the whole thing.

staggeringman · 20-02-2006, 01:28

yep your right gayle! dont want to be apart of anything political but at the end of the day could you see yourself being a two faced arsehole that promises everything and gets nothing..................thats what its all about and i dont even know politics.............

you are a lovely person from what i have seen and do you really want to do this (being 2 faced ....t) as all politicians are?

Gayle · 20-02-2006, 10:45

Quote:

Originally Posted by staggeringman

yep your right gayle! dont want to be apart of anything political but at the end of the day could you see yourself being a two faced arsehole that promises everything and gets nothing..................thats what its all about and i dont even know politics.............

you are a lovely person from what i have seen and do you really want to do this (being 2 faced ....t) as all politicians are?

Thank you, I think!

I'm doing this because I felt I had to - I couldn't stand by and let the current situation carry on. Someone had to stand up and be counted because things need to change.

Hopefully, one of the things that will change will be the openness, I couldn't be two faced if I tried, I tell everyone everything and believe that information needs to be out there as much as possible.

Neil · 20-02-2006, 11:48

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gayle

Obviously, I'm on here, as is Graham to answer for Labour and now the Lib Dem representative is hanging around it might prompt a Conservative to join in.

Why spoil a good forum with politicians?
Maybe you could use HyndburnLife for political stuff.
Anyway Graham usually does a disappearing act around election times.

andrewb · 20-02-2006, 12:03

Could be a good idea, although I think it's a good thing if people who wouldn't normaly get involved in politics read a thread and contribute, which they wouldn't do if it had a forum of its own..

However i'm a person with a view that everyone should vote, even if they're just going to the polling station to spoil their vote

Gayle · 20-02-2006, 12:07

Quote:

Originally Posted by Neil

Why spoil a good forum with politicians?

That's precisely why I was suggesting putting us all in a seperate area.

Neil · 20-02-2006, 12:59

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gayle

That's precisely why I was suggesting putting us all in a seperate area.

I hope your not suggesting that you all lick each other.

I personally think a policital forum could very quickly become chaotic. I suspect that is why you don't find many Councillors on here. If you need the assistance of your Councillor, then phone him/her.

Gayle · 20-02-2006, 15:00

I wasn't suggesting that only Councillors or candidates could post, just thought it could be a place where all political subjects could be discussed by everyone.

If people don't think it's a good idea we can just keep posting stuff in General Chat but I thought it might benefit the people who weren't interested because they'd be able to avoid it all.

KIPAX · 20-02-2006, 15:21

Top Idea IMHO

I am...eeerm a bit oldish.. I have never voted in my life... On the govermant I was once told by my mother (rip) that "It doesn't matter who you vote for.. Its just like swapping deckchairs on the Titanic"

Uninterested in who runs the country.. But at local level I could be persuaded to vote but have no idea whats what... That self satisfying greg pope needs turfing out of his comfy chair.. Is that what we are voting for next? I dunno

Anyways whatever the votes far its the personal touch and I would vote for Gayle purely from what I ahve seen on here rather than someone who knocks at my front door once in there lifetime and promises me the world

WillowTheWhisp · 20-02-2006, 16:41

It would be great if prospective candidates would come on here and tell us what they stand for and what they hope to do to benefit the comminity. Better than just those flying visits and leaflets through the door just before election time as Kipax said.

Wynonie Harris · 22-02-2006, 22:59

I think it's a great idea, but it won't just be confined to local politics, will it? I'm often on here knocking the present government (as, indeed, I would be if the Tories or Lib-Dems were in power) and I find it frustrating that no Labour party members will take me on! Maybe that will change if we have a political thread!

SPUGGIE J · 23-02-2006, 00:38

A lot of them aint got the bottle regardless of what level of polotics they are at. These people shouldcome on and read what we have to say as I reckon there is a lot of voters with broad political beliefs of all colours. Get tehm hear and lets see if they have backbones like iron rods or the backbone of a jellyfish.

Wynonie Harris · 24-02-2006, 08:03

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gayle

Obviously, I'm on here, as is Graham to answer for Labour

Does this only apply to local issues, Gayle? There is frequent criticism of the present Labour government on this site, yet it is invariably greeted with a resounding silence from both yourself and Councillor Jones! Why do you not want to defend your party's policies on national issues?

Gayle · 24-02-2006, 13:27

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wynonie Harris

Does this only apply to local issues, Gayle? There is frequent criticism of the present Labour government on this site, yet it is invariably greeted with a resounding silence from both yourself and Councillor Jones! Why do you not want to defend your party's policies on national issues?

I am fighting a local election on local issues, I will talk about them until the cows come home. I'm simply not qualified enough to answer or defend questions on national issues.

Wynonie Harris · 24-02-2006, 14:56

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gayle

I am fighting a local election on local issues, I will talk about them until the cows come home. I'm simply not qualified enough to answer or defend questions on national issues.

A very good politician's answer, Gayle!

However, you are a member of the Labour party and, therefore, you must have strong views on national political topics. I accept that you are perhaps caught between a rock and a hard place...defend the policies of this government and you risk alienating potential voters, criticize the government's policies and you risk being regarded as "off-message" by the party bigwigs.

Nevertheless, it is a pity. A lot of the threads which criticize the government on here simply end up as a series of posts agreeing with each other. It would have been interesting to hear the opposite point of view. Perhaps, after the election, you may be persuaded to enter the cut-and-thrust of national political debate?