Joy Division/new Order

maxwell silver · 02-06-2007, 08:28

One for the lads.Which one did you prefer?The manc miserablists and their songs of despair or their reincarnation as electro-dance happy chart toppers.Did you think 'blue monday' was a better song than 'love will tear us apart'.Was Curtis' suicide a blessing in disguise for the rest of the band.To be honest i think New Order just edge it for me as nowadays i find some of JD's stuff difficult to listen to(a couple of songs off 'Closer' anyhow).Or maybe i'm showing my age.From

to

.

Alvin the chipmunk · 02-06-2007, 13:08

Joy division - Sure they made you feel like topping yourself but you cant deny they made great music. Almost went beserk when

maxwell silver · 02-06-2007, 19:11

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alvin the chipmunk

Joy division - Sure they made you feel like topping yourself but you cant deny they made great music. Almost went beserk when

When what.....i think we should be told

Wynonie Harris · 02-06-2007, 19:21

Utter and complete garbage, both of 'em. Listen to a different song called Blue Monday by the mighty Fats Domino and hear what REAL music is like!

maxwell silver · 02-06-2007, 19:35

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wynonie Harris

Utter and complete garbage, both of 'em. Listen to a different song called Blue Monday by the mighty Fats Domino and hear what REAL music is like!

Fair enough.Iquite expected a reply like that from an old time skiffle-billy like yourself.Fats' 'Blue monday' maybe a good tune,but i think were talking a generation or 2 onwards.P.S...did they have synths,samples & anything resembling 'techno' when Fats was giving us more blues than JD could have ever managed.I don't think so.Your quite welcome to your opiion.Dear me,some of the songs i'm on about are nearly 30 years old,i know your an old timer but come on to my generation some of these songs will last forever.

Wynonie Harris · 02-06-2007, 19:53

Quote:

Originally Posted by maxwell silver

did they have synths,samples & anything resembling 'techno'

Works of the devil!...electrickery!

shakermaker · 02-06-2007, 20:21

I'd have to go for Joy Division.
Not one of my favourite bands at all but Transmission, Ceremony & Love Will Tear Us Apart are great songs.

I despise Blue Monday & in turn can't stand any New Order songs.

maxwell silver · 02-06-2007, 20:25

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wynonie Harris

Works of the devil!...electrickery!

Century 21 coming to a town near you soon

No offence.

Wynonie Harris · 02-06-2007, 20:47

Quote:

Originally Posted by maxwell silver

Century 21 coming to a town near you soon

No offence.

Actually, you're probably right there, Manchester is about a hundred yards away at the bottom of the street. However, it's strictly 50's/60's stuff (and bands who play in that idiom) in this house. And what's all this "no offence" stuff? Like yourself, I came up in a tough school (Ralph Bailey's), so please feel free to give me all the "offence" you want!

maxwell silver · 02-06-2007, 21:32

[ And what's all this "no offence" stuff? Like yourself, I came up in a tough school (Ralph Bailey's), so please feel free to give me all the "offence" you want!

[/quote]
Well like yourself then you were taught to show the older gener ation some respect.You old git,every offence intended

Wynonie Harris · 02-06-2007, 21:37

Quote:

Originally Posted by maxwell silver

You old git

That's what we used to call hapless OAPs as they shuffled past the deck 40 years ago. And now I'm one! Bleedin' beat groups...bash, bash, bash, just a noise, that's all it is. Exits stage left to pour another Johnnie Walker.

AccyJay · 02-06-2007, 21:41

Quote:

Originally Posted by shakermaker

I'd have to go for Joy Division.
Not one of my favourite bands at all but Transmission, Ceremony & Love Will Tear Us Apart are great songs.

I despise Blue Monday & in turn can't stand any New Order songs.

I loved Transmission. Also can't stand Blue Monday. I must admit though, I prefer New order.

Mancie · 02-06-2007, 23:53

I prefer Joy Division as the music was still pretty raw .... New Order's 1st album after Ian Curtis (Movement) was very good ...they still sounded like JD but a little smoother round the edges... never really got into the dance techno stuff from them after that.
Wynonie seems to only like the kind of stuff were bods jump on top of pianos screaming stuff like " wap bobolopop a wam bambo" !

garinda · 03-06-2007, 00:33

Kraftwerk meets rainy Manchester.

It was always going to end in tears.

Wynonie Harris · 03-06-2007, 08:01

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mancie

Wynonie seems to only like the kind of stuff were bods jump on top of pianos screaming stuff like " wap bobolopop a wam bambo" !

That should be "Awopbopaloobopalopbamboom"! If you must quote the mighty Little Richard Penniman, get it right, Mancie!

Incidentally, you Manc music types might care to investigate Vinyl Revival at 5 Hilton Street (just off Oldham Street) next time you're in the metropolis. He seems to have plenty of Smiths/New Order and all that sort of malarky in stock, including posters and t-shirts.