Should Robbie Go 'Back For Good'?

flashy · 27-03-2009, 08:29

Robbie Williams said he would love to go back to Take That and he's just waiting for Gary Barlow to make that phone call...

personally i DONT think he should go back....Robbie is a singer now in his own right and an excellent one at that....Take That came back and have done brilliantly well

now Robbie doesnt need to be in the band, he has enough mmoney now to set him up for the rest of his life

i reckon it would spoil things if he came back, maybe a one off concert with all 5 of them would be good, but nothing after that

leave them all as they are, it certainly works for me that way

shakermaker · 27-03-2009, 08:39

Take That have made the most (and imho, only) credible music of their career since the reformation four years ago.

They've made the journey from hyped-up-boyband-crap to the land of proper music (something Boyzone have failed to do miserably).

They've done this without that fat dancer from Stoke, and now as his career his practically over, he wants in. Surprise surprise, chuck.

If they do let him back in the band it will be a decision driven purely by money as he could only work in detriment to the band, musically.

Man, this post looks like a stretched out haiku.

flashy · 27-03-2009, 08:42

i agree with you shaker...well to a point anyway, i dont think Robbie's career is over just yet, but i do agree that Take Thats 'new' work is some of their best yet

i think if he does go back then it will be all over for the band

emzy · 27-03-2009, 09:52

I'd say no! Deffinately not.

I never liked take that before but am finding myself a bit of a fan now, but also like some of robbies own stuff. I think that Robbie is better as a solo artist than part of a group.

jaysay · 27-03-2009, 11:28

Quote:

Originally Posted by flashy

i agree with you shaker...well to a point anyway, i dont think Robbie's career is over just yet, but i do agree that Take Thats 'new' work is some of their best yet

i think if he does go back then it will be all over for the band

That's a good enough reason not to take him back flashy, personally I think he's a nut job now, and definitely past his sell by date. He now appears in the press for anything but singing, he's definitely away with the fairies

harwood red · 27-03-2009, 13:09

I agree with all of the above...nuff said

katex · 27-03-2009, 14:31

Suppose you have got to ask 'what has he got to offer by rejoining ?'. Guess not much really.

pipinfort · 27-03-2009, 14:37

A one off spot singing `Could It Be Magic`/`Everything Changes` at one of Take Thats summer spectaculars ( Old Trafford sat 27th July please for the sake of the missus) is all i think it needs to put the `Ghost` to rest, Robbie is far better on his own as are Take That..........so i ain`t voted because its not an option.......

Mancie · 27-03-2009, 16:47

Quote:

Originally Posted by pipinfort

A one off spot singing `Could It Be Magic`/`Everything Changes` at one of Take Thats summer spectaculars ( Old Trafford sat 27th July please for the sake of the missus) is all i think it needs to put the `Ghost` to rest, Robbie is far better on his own as are Take That..........so i ain`t voted because its not an option.......

Take That at Old Trafford

!...thank god I found out it is at Old Trafford cricket ground..almost gave me a heart attack...I had this image of cigarette lighters being waved about in the Streford End during "a million love songs"

Mancie · 27-03-2009, 17:37

I don't think him re-joining would do the rest of them any good

Lolly · 27-03-2009, 19:50

Quote:

Originally Posted by pipinfort

A one off spot singing `Could It Be Magic`/`Everything Changes` at one of Take Thats summer spectaculars ( Old Trafford sat 27th July please for the sake of the missus) is all i think it needs to put the `Ghost` to rest, Robbie is far better on his own as are Take That..........so i ain`t voted because its not an option.......

Hes already done that on their first tour back (sort of!) He recorded his hologram specially for the tour.

If he does do a one off as long as its not at Wembley Stadium on 4th July!!! I'll be very mad!

To me now Take That are 4! I've seen them live with 5 members and with 4 members and trust me from a live point of view they are much better now!

flashy · 27-03-2009, 19:58

not seen that before, cheers Laurie

pipinfort · 27-03-2009, 20:10

[quote=Lolly;697491]Hes already done that on their first tour back (sort of!) He recorded his hologram specially for the tour.quote]

But a hologram is`nt real is it..........

katex · 27-03-2009, 20:33

To be honest, did vote 'don't care a chuff' .. they do appear to write some 'lovely little songs', but why are they all so ugly and little. Not like the pop singers in our day ... when at least they were reasonably handsome ....

panther · 27-03-2009, 20:57

He only wants to join because Take that are doing better than him!!.....****** off Robbie, ya an has-been!!