Accy's strongest 11 - Page 2

Wynonie Harris · 24-02-2011, 22:02

Quote:

Originally Posted by football19

Long time red,sorry if you found my post obnoxious,wasnt intended that way,What i meant to say was that the best starting eleven is normally based on the opposition,therefore JC and JB may pick players to do a certain job,example,Long is better equipped to deal with a big centre forward,were Hessey is better dealing with a smaller quick player.
To say whos the better player is unfair,and your right i did skim thro the posts,I must try harder next time !!!

I hate to stick my oar in, but it was Red Blooded who found your post "obnoxious". I think he needs to get acquainted a bit more with our slightly off-the-wall banter on here!

Chimer · 24-02-2011, 22:10

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Red Blooded

To be fair how do you know they are more qualified than anyone else? For all you know I may be Sir Alex Fergerson.

I think if you were Sir Alex you wouldn't have spelt Ferguson like that ....

Sorry!

football19 · 24-02-2011, 22:33

Red blooded,I have now read your first post and just a few comments, playing Hessey at right back,hes a centre back whos left footed!,JC tried him at left back and it didnt work!!!,Did you go to the preston game recently?,Chris was tried in your suggested position and he was like a duck out of water and he got subbed.
If you dont do it at resis level you wont get a sniff at first team level.
Regarding Deano,who you dont like,HES A DEFENDER,first and foremost,playing every game but one ( lost 3-1),and the team has only lost 8 league games,and hes not playing in his prefered centre back position due to Phil playing so well,so he cant be doing that badly.
Finally sean mac is not a forward,hes more effective in a roaming roll facing goal,not with his back to it as Gornall is so good at

/

Redraine · 24-02-2011, 23:29

Quote:

Originally Posted by football19

Finally sean mac is not a forward,hes more effective in a roaming roll facing goal,not with his back to it as Gornall is so good at/

Sorry,19, but I had to laugh at that. Is he a hippopotamus, now?

Only at home. of course.

football19 · 25-02-2011, 14:33

Redraine,hands up,thats a very witty reply!!!!!,Theres too many sharp people on this web site,i will be getting a complex soon.
PS I did forecast last july that sean mac would have a good season,and hes not letting me down yet!!!!

maccawozzagod · 25-02-2011, 15:37

i once posted a thread asking people who they thought our best XI ever was (pound for pound at all levels) and got half a dozen indignant replies that the current one is the best ever undisputably (must have been the 1st season in the FL)

For what its worth.

Dunbavin
Bateson Edwards Long Jacobson
Proctor Joyce
Ryan Barnett Putterill
Gornall

Winnard loses out as JJ offers more going forwards in my opinion and Id like to see Deano play more at centre half as and when required - but he offers great versatility right across the line

Craney loses out as I think the other three attacking midfielders offer more regular effort and all four are equally as gifted in different ways at cerating match winning moments. Putterill has to play more often to get back to his mazy runs.

Sean Mc loses out for a whole host of reasons but I like to know he's there on the bench. Crewe winning goal was fantastic but he doesn't do anywhere near enough of that.

Boulding and Linfield won't even make the bench Im afraid and will have to pay £13 to come in

new red · 26-02-2011, 12:38

Very valid points Macca. i too would try a different backline at times and include Bateson rather than Deano. Good player but other players could more than fill his boots and offer more in some games.
Also agree re Boulding and Lindfield. They dont offer any real threat from the bench.

smudgie · 26-02-2011, 12:42

Dunbavin
Bateson
Long
Hessey
Jacobsen
Joyce
Proctor
Ryan
Barnett
Craney
Gornell

Subs
Cisak
Edwards
Winnard
Mcconville
Putterill
Boulding
Turner

shakermaker · 26-02-2011, 12:44

Quote:

Originally Posted by smudgie

Subs
Cisak
Edwards
Winnard
Mcconville
Putterill
Boulding
Turner

Brave!!!

smudgie · 26-02-2011, 13:02

I know mate, I just feel Phil keeps making alot of mistakes, and with the way Hessey is playing.......... alongside Long would be immense

VALAIRIAN · 26-02-2011, 20:24

The way Hess played today, he would not get on the bench!!!!

cashman · 26-02-2011, 20:31

Beats me how anyone can include Proccy in a strongest 11, good 100% er no question, but strongest 11? yer havin a laugh.

football19 · 27-02-2011, 13:50

Must disagree mr Cashman,Proctor is a very effective player,always gives 100%,and is probably Accis best defensive midfielder.
Regarding this thread,the strongest 11 is not necessarly the best team 11,
Its all about combinations,10 messi,s wouldnt make Barca a better team.
( although they would be entertaining!!).

maccawozzagod · 27-02-2011, 14:05

Proccy first name on t'sheet fer me Cashy.

cashman · 27-02-2011, 16:37

Quote:

Originally Posted by football19

Must disagree mr Cashman,Proctor is a very effective player,always gives 100%,and is probably Accis best defensive midfielder.
Regarding this thread,the strongest 11 is not necessarly the best team 11,
Its all about combinations,10 messi,s wouldnt make Barca a better team.
( although they would be entertaining!!).

I said he was a good 100% player, n as fer 10 messi's if yeh have bothered to read other posts yeh would know what i think about that.

we will have to disagree on hes accys best defensive player, watch how many times he stands n waits fer the ball to come to him, n how many times the ball is lost through it, then tell me the same.