murdoch.....

stanley2011 · 26-10-2011, 14:58

Does anybody know why he isnt playing. we only lost one in eight when he was playing and we have now lost the last four possibly 5 on saturday. also any news on any more loan signings or players coming in? thanks

JEFF · 26-10-2011, 15:04

Quote:

Originally Posted by stanley2011

Does anybody know why he isnt playing. we only lost one in eight when he was playing and we have now lost the last four possibly 5 on saturday.

Ask Mr Coleman, he is the only one who knows why, nobody else has any idea or reasoning.

John_Timmins · 26-10-2011, 15:21

Don't think bavs put a foot wrong last night tbh...and saved two one on one chances for shrews

fc:stanley · 26-10-2011, 15:58

Bavs was solid last night and pulled of an absolute top save when there player came in with a bullet header. Kicking improved last night aswell! Id stick with Bavs.

JEFF · 26-10-2011, 16:04

Quote:

Originally Posted by fc:stanley

Bavs was solid last night and pulled of an absolute top save when there player came in with a bullet header. Kicking improved last night aswell! Id stick with Bavs.

You would "stick with Bavs" until he makes a mess again and costs us more points. As has been stated many times Bavs is a good shot stopper but his decisions sometimes cost us games. Murdoch has done nothing wrong why not "stick with him" ?

fc:stanley · 26-10-2011, 16:08

Quote:

Originally Posted by JEFF

You would "stick with Bavs" until he makes a mess again and costs us more points. As has been stated many times Bavs is a good shot stopper but his decisions sometimes cost us games. Murdoch has done nothing wrong why not "stick with him" ?

Dont know Jeff! Im not manager. Maybe hes not doing well in training? Maybes hes got a knock? Maybe hes got a bad attitude? Who knows, there must be something that coley isnt picking him!

Bavs did play well last night! Good kicking, bossed his box, always talking to defenders and pulled of two great saves!

Just to add Dean Winnard And Kev Long were both immense last night!

football19 · 26-10-2011, 18:22

Rostyn was a team mate of Deano for years at blackburn.
Very good player with a great touch ( and a rocket shot).
Couldnt believe when he returned to Oz,as he had a great future ahead of him.
Would be playing at championship level now in my opinion.
Another lad who played with them,Bryan Hodge was also a cracking player,but is now playing in Scotland somewhere,a waste really

football19 · 26-10-2011, 18:24

Should have posted the above,under another heading ---sorry!!!

mab · 26-10-2011, 20:58

Quote:

Originally Posted by JEFF

You would "stick with Bavs" until he makes a mess again and costs us more points. As has been stated many times Bavs is a good shot stopper but his decisions sometimes cost us games. Murdoch has done nothing wrong why not "stick with him" ?

His Distribution of the ball is at question here,and this is the problem!! No one saying that he an't a good keeper just hid distibution from catches or saves,look at the tranmere game (first one) when we scored it was Bavs quick Distibution of the ball to McIntyre whos cross was deflected in,i understand where your coming from Jeff with Bavs walk abouts but hes only been at fault with one and that was off-side by a couple of yards.

AccyAggro · 26-10-2011, 21:20

Prefer Murdoch over Bavs to be honest, purely because murdoch hasnt really done anything wrong while he's bin in goals and bavs in prone to a mistake every too often, despite bein a world beater at times!

cashman · 26-10-2011, 21:33

If there was only shot stopping to a keepers game bavs may be a world beater, as there is a lot more to goalkeeping, Bavs couldn't beat n egg.

mab · 26-10-2011, 21:38

Quote:

Originally Posted by AccyAggro

Prefer Murdoch over Bavs to be honest, purely because murdoch hasnt really done anything wrong while he's bin in goals and bavs in prone to a mistake every too often, despite bein a world beater at times!

Could say the same about Bav's

cashman · 26-10-2011, 21:51

This debate will go on forever, go back to last season- The defence played better when Cisak was in goal, Murdochs done ok this term, it aint a matter of like or dislike Dunbavin, the defence seems to me to have more confidence when someone else is in goal, thats how i see things simple.

JEFF · 27-10-2011, 09:17

Quote:

Originally Posted by mab

i understand where your coming from Jeff with Bavs walk abouts but hes only been at fault with one and that was off-side by a couple of yards.

He's only been at fault with one THIS SEASON, what about all the rest ?

Exile on Spencer St · 27-10-2011, 13:20

I'll be at the match on Saturday. Is there any chance Dunbavin and Murdoch will both be in the team?