11-11-2008, 15:42
|
#18
|
Senior Member+
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Down 'Amnesia Alley !'
Posts: 2,913
Liked: 1559 times
Rep Power: 115701
|
Re: Stuart Hall
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mik Griff
What the frig is up with this guy, and who on earth chose him to narrate the documentary, he really gets in my bloody nerves, and his **** poor lancashire accent!
|
I expect that Stuart, his Intonation, and demeanour in general does get on the b....y nerves of many others as well Mik. What one has to remember though, as far as 'Accrington Stanley...Exactly' was concerned, is that Firstly as a professional presenter of long standing, particularly in the North West of England, any Director of this sort of Documentary programmes would look to Stuart's 'persona' as being eminently suitable for the
presenter's task !.. This would be why he was given the job !.
Secondly, any performer is only as good as the material which his or her writer(s) provide for them. It is not surprising then that in many of the 'scenes' where Eric,
Mick, and Rob et al were not involved in the fascinating
dialogue on screen, Stuart's flowery and 'homely' description of the action did tend to grate a bit on the senses !. The Writer attempting to match Stuarts' 'delivery' !
I know that Stuart Hall is a committed and hard-working Broadcaster, and always gives of his best to whatever programme he is involved with. But, like other performers he has created for himself a style to which he feels he has to conform, an 'Image' to maintain, and thus is bound to have his detractors !.
That you don't seem to care for this style matches my
feelings towards Bruce Forsyth, amongst others. But isn't this what all branches of the performing arts engenders in us all ?. A personal appreciation or rejection of the Actors, Singers, Dancers, AND documentary presenters who parade before us,' doing their thing'.
|
|
|