Who can cut it in Div 1? - Page 5

Inspector Morse · 09-05-2018, 08:46

By O Sullivan I did mean the version we had first time- if he could get back to that form he'd be a real asset.

Saying that he would have a job shifting Jordan Clarke but could provide options both wide and centrally.

maccawozzagod · 09-05-2018, 09:37

Theres no guarantee that Clarke will be with us next season, as a young man with a medal round his neck, and one of our better players, I've no doubt he'll be courted elsewhere.

Players like Billy and Sean MAY be happy where they are and less interested in bench warming elsewhere à la Pearson and McCartan

monkey hanger · 10-05-2018, 09:48

Quote:

Originally Posted by maccawozzagod

Theres no guarantee that Clarke will be with us next season, as a young man with a medal round his neck, and one of our better players, I've no doubt he'll be courted elsewhere.

Players like Billy and Sean MAY be happy where they are and less interested in bench warming elsewhere à la Pearson and McCartan

its all about money anyway. the players mentioned are all under contract and so we would get a good fee for em and being a bench warmer on more money might be an attraction. best job in football is the understudy keeper at a premier league club. loads of dosh without game time. if their regular gets injured they,d sign another as well if its in the window.

football19 · 10-05-2018, 10:13

O’Sullivan is a class act when he decides to turn up !!!
You can argue hes had some bad injures,but IMO,its the bit between his ears thats stopped him progressing,hes got the lot in his locker.

Twenty Eight · 10-05-2018, 12:32

Quote:

Originally Posted by maccawozzagod

Theres no guarantee that Clarke will be with us next season, as a young man with a medal round his neck, and one of our better players, I've no doubt he'll be courted elsewhere.

Players like Billy and Sean MAY be happy where they are and less interested in bench warming elsewhere à la Pearson and McCartan

He's under contract for another year with an option for another year after that. He wont be going anywhere unless the club wants / allows him to leave.

He also has a league two runner up medal.

Chrisr · 10-05-2018, 19:53

It will be interesting to see who is at the club for next season. The comings and goings will throw up a lot of speculation before the final team is shaped up. Up to signing the keeper from Guiseley Chappers was a poor keeper. He then suddenly realised he had to up his game and proved to be a good keeper like he was when he first came on loan before he got injured. Bill is a goal poacher but has not got the legs these days, I doubt if he would be able to cut in League 1. Jackson would and the sub Zatlan. Ben would be an ideal defender for that division. Will Jimmy Dunne still be available to us. I don't know but if not I wish him well. if he stays it would be a master stroke on coley's behalf. If Burnley decide he can go there will be a scramble for him. Would Mark Hughes cut it in league 1. Possibly but has he got the speed left in his legs? There are others who are questionable or would stay. This thread will run for a good while. It will be another part of the equation when we know who else is available. All opinions are as valid as each others for discussion sake. Ultimately Coley's decision will be the final one.

monkey hanger · 11-05-2018, 08:42

its difficult to really say who will come off in div.1 and who will not. could be in for a surprise as some who did well last season may struggle and others may adapt better who were not regulars. how many of our squad who we have kept have played div.1 football i wonder. any help out there.

Inspector Morse · 11-05-2018, 09:14

I don't class Billy as just a goal poacher though he can finish. He's probably our best footballer and his hold up/link play can be fantastic. The only limit to Billy will come from himself and how much re really wants to play at a higher level given his issues. I would certainly love to see him leading the line next season.

Re Chapman. I put his rejuvenation down to being dropped for the Morecombe away game.

cashman · 11-05-2018, 10:09

Billys hold up play and Link up, is as inspector morse said second to none in my view, speed has never been his asset, but common sense has, i think he will be fine in league 1,

Lord Didsbury · 11-05-2018, 13:19

John Sheridan was the best player I ever saw outside the top flight. He was the reason I started going watching footy again in the mid 80s. Head and shoulders above everyone else, a joy to watch with his vision and skill.... yet was very ordinary in the top division (despite what wikipedia might say!). Other players such as Batty and Strachan performed just as well in both divisions.

I don't think it's just down to speed/fitness, but it's one of the major factors. Akinfenwa, i suspect, might be a handful and score at any level (outside the premier league) even though he's a slow coach.

I reckon we may be a bit too slow/lightweight through the spine of the team..... would love to see that bolstering.

If anyone can, Coley can.

Inspector Morse · 11-05-2018, 14:35

Was Sheridan not playmaker for the cracking Sheff Wed team of the early 90's? 9(Hirst, Waddle , Carlton Palmer ahemetc) He always looked sheer class when I saw him on tv for both Wednesday and ROI.

Twenty Eight · 11-05-2018, 17:47

Indeed he was so I’m baffled by Lord D’s “ordinary” comment.
I’m sure Manchester United didn’t think he was ordinary in 1991 when he scored the winner at Wembley .......

Twenty Eight · 11-05-2018, 17:49

Can’t wait to see which Manager’s job he gets.

Chewbacca · 11-05-2018, 18:42

Quote:

Originally Posted by Twenty Eight

Indeed he was so I’m baffled by Lord D’s “ordinary” comment.
I’m sure Manchester United didn’t think he was ordinary in 1991 when he scored the winner at Wembley .......

He wasn't top flight then and they were only playing a mid-table div 1 team in the reserve cup.

Twenty Eight · 11-05-2018, 18:54

Closet Man Ure fan surfaces !
If you live in Accy probably the most local fan they’ve got.