who starts Elliot or Dunbavin?????

ben 107 the bee · 20-10-2006, 10:55

Just wondering whatevery body else thinks.
simply who should start tomorrow?

John_Timmins · 20-10-2006, 11:00

dunbavin hasnt done anything wrong and shouldnt be dropped until he does something wrong

K.S.H · 20-10-2006, 11:03

I think it should/will be Dunbavin, they prob put Elliot in on Tue to give Ian a break, I aint bothered either way though, both of them do a great job

spud · 20-10-2006, 11:11

I think Elliot should play, reason being if he's not getting a game here, they're gonna send him somewhere that will and after tuesday night clubs are gonna be queing round the block.

baldy · 20-10-2006, 11:14

Quote:

Originally Posted by spud

I think Elliot should play, reason being if he's not getting a game here, they're gonna send him somewhere that will and after tuesday night clubs are gonna be queing round the block.

I see what you mean Spud but "why try to fix what aint broke"

spud · 20-10-2006, 11:18

Quote:

Originally Posted by baldy

I see what you mean Spud but "why try to fix what aint broke"

I would happily see bavs play tomorrow, i just don't wanna see elliot leave, that's all

AccyMad · 20-10-2006, 11:22

I'm happy with either of them in the nets, not something I thought I'd say when we signed Ian, I'll hold my hands up that I was one of those who had serious doubts about him but he's proved us wrong and fair play to the lad. I certainly wouldn't like to be the one who has to make the decision either.

harwood red · 20-10-2006, 11:29

Quote:

Originally Posted by AccyMad

I'm happy with either of them in the nets, not something I thought I'd say when we signed Ian, I'll hold my hands up that I was one of those who had serious doubts about him but he's proved us wrong and fair play to the lad. I certainly wouldn't like to be the one who has to make the decision either.

My thoughts exactly

maccawozzagod · 20-10-2006, 11:30

Dunbavin, dun driving, dun keeping

sorry, either of em but I still prefer Rob.

quality Elliot Bavs

shot stopping excellent excellent
command area excellent reasonable
distribution throw excellent reasonable
distribution kick reasonable good
penalties God Gods best friend

so Rob wins by two excellents and a best friend to nil. And besides, Robs got a fatter arse so would leave space for an extra bum in the dug out

cmonstanley · 20-10-2006, 22:20

i would pick dubavin caus if it werent for him we would be probabably be in the bottom 4 and thats no exageration

maccawozzagod · 20-10-2006, 23:20

but if Elliot had been fit we would be roughly where we are now and Bavs would have splinters in his @rse

cmonstanley · 20-10-2006, 23:56

maybe maybe not we will never know

yerself · 21-10-2006, 06:27

I think Rob Elliot. Surely Charlton didn't let us have him on a season long loan to play in a league two reserve team.

John_Timmins · 21-10-2006, 10:59

what so your going to turn around to bavs OUR keeper and say youve played fantastic but cause robbie is from a premiership side he has to play!!!

I know it sounds harsh to robbie after all the things he has done for us but you have to look after your own especially if they are playing so well

cmonstanley · 21-10-2006, 11:46

Quote:

Originally Posted by John_Timmins

what so your going to turn around to bavs OUR keeper and say youve played fantastic but cause robbie is from a premiership side he has to play!!!

I know it sounds harsh to robbie after all the things he has done for us but you have to look after your own especially if they are playing so well

agree 100% what would happen if charlton called elliot back what would we be left with a goalkeeper short on confidence and lack of first game fitness i still say dunbavin